The Perse School
  • Parent Login
  • Pupil and Staff Login
  • Calendar
  • Sports Fixtures
  • Term dates
  • Search
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Explore
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • Sixth Form Life
    • People
    • The Perse Today
    • Summer School
    • Contact
    • Job Vacancies
    • Policies and Inspection
    • Events
    • Keep in Touch
    • Support Us
    • Get Involved
    • Notable Alumni
    • Head's Blog
    • News Stories
    • Parent Login
    • Pupil and Staff Login
    • Calendar
    • Sports Fixtures
    • Term dates

Peers, parents or school?

← Previous
Next →

The 1966 Coleman report famously found that schools had a very limited effect on the academic attainment of children.

The education, income and social class of parents outweighed school quality as measured by class size, teacher experience, and school expenditure by a factor of 5:1 in determining pupil performance.

Subsequent research has largely supported these conclusions.  Schools make a 20% difference to a child’s academic achievement, but parenting, inherited intelligence, and family circumstances are more important controls.  So where does this leave the significant investment parents make in independent education?  Private schools typically market themselves by concentrating on the perceived advantages of outstanding facilities and small classes.  Yet the evidence suggests these bring limited benefits.

What does matter is the peer group effect.  In selective independent schools the benefits inculcated by a peer group comprised of children of similar high ability and industry are considerable.  Bright children thrive in the company of other bright children, they spark off one another, and encourage each other to even higher levels of attainment.  Such children create a school culture in which it is cool to succeed and where learning is celebrated.  This can be reinforced by excellent teaching and school leadership.

Research suggests that the peer group effect outweighs parental influence and is the largest control on educational outcome.  However, if concentrating talented children in one institution works for bright pupils, the same cannot be said for grouping underachieving children together.  There is a palpable ‘sink effect’, where weaker children live down to their label and learn bad habits from each other.  Academic selection works at the top of the ability range, but not at the bottom.

Given that teaching is a graduate profession it is unsurprising that academic attainment in schools is highly prized.  However we live in a world of multiple intelligences and academic success is not the only form of achievement.  I have a twin brother.  I did well at school academically; he thrived in practical subjects.  We were both successful but in different ways.

All children have latent talents and schools have a duty to realise them.  Selection by academic ability does not work for all, but selection by talents could.  By concentrating academic, practical, and sporting children together in schools specialising in their strengths, formidable and positive peer groups are created.  Children become excited by shared interests; they succeed in their specialisms and this positive feedback generates further enthusiasm and improvement.

Selection, so long the dirty word in British education could become the driving force for improvement.  But it must be selection by talent and not just by academic ability.  We must celebrate all forms of success, whether academic, practical, creative, emotional or sporting and recognise that positive peer groups of pupils who share common talents and interests will drive up standards.  All children need a base level of academic education.  Beyond that grouping by talent engages students, raises standards and realises potential.

Categories

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Google+
  • Email

Join the
conversation

Your details

Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. 19 Mar 2012

    Ed Elliott, Head

    Leo, good to see you are still showing an interest in The Perse. The research I was referring to is 'Do Peer Groups Matter?' Economica 2003 70; 31-53 by Robertson and Symons.
  2. 14 Mar 2012

    Leo

    "Subsequent research", "Research suggests" - where are my references!?

Latest Posts

18 Nov 2020

A Personal Perspective on Public Exams in a Pandemic

5 Sep 2020

Learning Covid Lessons

18 Nov 2019

The do’s and don’ts of university interviews

Read moreSee more

Blog Archive

2020

November
1
September
1

2019

November
1
September
2
March
2
February
1
January
1

2018

October
1
July
1
April
1
February
1
January
1

2017

November
1
September
1
March
4
January
1

2016

November
1
October
1
September
1
June
1
January
1

2015

October
1
May
2
February
2
January
2

2014

December
4
November
3
October
1
September
3
August
1
June
1
May
1
April
1
March
3
February
1
January
3

2013

December
2
November
3
October
2
September
4
August
3
July
1
June
3
May
4
April
2
March
3
February
3
January
5

2012

December
2
November
4
October
6
September
7
August
4
July
3
June
3
May
5
April
3
March
4
February
4
January
5

2011

December
3
November
2
Return to startUp periscope

The Perse Pelican
Head: Francesca Heftman
92 Glebe Road
Cambridge
CB1 7TD

T +44 (0) 1223 403940

The Perse Prep
Head: James Piper
Trumpington Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EX

T +44 (0) 1223 403920

The Perse Upper
Head: Ed Elliott
Hills Road
Cambridge
CB2 8QF

T +44 (0) 1223 403800

  • Contact
  • Job Vacancies
  • Our Vision, Values and Aims
  • Term Dates
  • Inspection Report
  • Governors
  • Perse Studio
  • Policies
  • Safeguarding and Child Protection Policy
  • Privacy Notices
  • Disclaimer
  • Website Terms of Use
pelican@perse.co.uk
prep@perse.co.uk
schooloffice@perse.co.uk
Twitter Facebook YouTube Instagram

© The Perse School 2021. All Rights reserved.
Crafted by The District and Chameleon Studios

 
Toggle the navigation
 
The Perse School
Parent Login Calendar Site Search
  • Homepage
  • Upcoming Lecture: Mobile Apps become Medical Devices 
  • About us 
    • The Perse Today 
      • Our vision, values and aims 
        • Sustainability 
      • Philosophy 
      • Outreach and Community Partnerships 
      • Governors 
      • Perse in Cambridge 
      • Rooted in History 
        • Timeline 
      • Expanding our Facilities 
    • Summer School 
    • Contact 
      • Open Events 
      • Request Prospectus 
      • Book a Tour 
    • Job Vacancies 
  • Pelican 
    • Admissions 
      • Request Prospectus 
      • Open Morning 
      • Book a Tour 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
        • Nursery and Reception 
        • Years 1 and 2 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Club Pelican 
    • School Life 
      • Home from Home 
      • The School Day 
      • Pelican Behaviour 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet a few of our Pelican staff 
      • Parents’ Association 
  • Prep 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Visiting the Prep 
        • Open Morning 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Taster Morning 
        • Activity Morning 
        • Pre-Test Service 
      • Prep 360 Virtual Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
      • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Assessment 
      • Learning Support 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs 
      • Drama + Music 
      • Sport 
    • School Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The School Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • The House System 
      • School Council 
      • Newsletter 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet a few of our Prep Staff 
      • Parents’ Association 
  • Upper 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Open Days 
      • Visiting the Upper 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Taster Morning 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
        • Help with Fees 
      • Scholarships 
      • Joining Us 
        • Linking Project 
        • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Independent Research 
      • Enrichment 
      • Exam Results 
      • Learning Support 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs + Societies 
        • The 42 Society 
      • Drama + Dance 
      • Music 
      • Outdoor Pursuits 
      • Sport 
      • Peter Hall Performing Arts Centre 
    • School Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The School Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • The House System 
      • Student Council 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet the Staff 
  • 6th Form 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Visiting the Sixth Form 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Open Evening 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
        • International Students 
      • Fees 
        • Help with Fees 
      • Scholarships 
      • Joining Us 
        • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Independent Research 
      • Enrichment 
      • Learning Support 
      • Exam Results 
      • University 
        • University destinations 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs + Societies 
        • The 42 
      • Drama + dance 
      • Music 
      • Outdoor Pursuits 
      • Sport 
    • Sixth Form Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The Sixth Form Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • Student Council 
    • People 
      • Staff list 
      • Meet the Staff 
  • Alumni 
    • Events 
    • Keep in Touch 
      • OP News 
      • E-Newsletter 
        • Perse Profiles 
        • Into The Archive 
        • Recent Events 
      • Find a Friend 
      • Update Form 
      • Contact Us 
      • E-Communications 
    • Support Us 
      • Make a Gift 
      • Bursaries 
      • 2021 Leavers’ Gift 
      • Outreach 
      • Legacies 
      • Donor Recognition 
    • Get Involved 
      • Year Group Reps 
      • Networking & Careers 
      • 42 Society Lectures 
    • Notable Alumni 
  • News 
  • Head's Blog
  • Contact
  • Calendar
  • Sport Fixtures
  • Term Dates
  • Close Menu  Close Menu
  • Parent Login
  • Pupil + Staff Login
  • Close Menu  Close Menu
  • Twitter
  • Facebook