The Perse School
  • Parent Login
  • Pupil and Staff Login
  • Calendar
  • Sports Fixtures
  • Term dates
  • Search
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Explore
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • School Life
    • People
    • Admissions
    • Academic
    • Beyond Classroom
    • Sixth Form Life
    • People
    • The Perse Today
    • Summer School
    • Contact
    • Job Vacancies
    • Policies and Inspection
    • Events
    • Keep in Touch
    • Support Us
    • Get Involved
    • Notable Alumni
    • Head's Blog
    • News Stories
    • Parent Login
    • Pupil and Staff Login
    • Calendar
    • Sports Fixtures
    • Term dates

Independent schools and public benefit

← Previous
Next →

Independent schools are rightly proud of their independence. It allows them to act in the best interests of the pupils, parents and communities they serve free from political influence and bureaucratic control.

Independent schools provide an excellent education because they are independent and because they are well funded. Politicians are keen for independent schools to sponsor state academies so that they can pass on their ‘DNA’. This ‘DNA’ includes some excellent educational practices and partly explains why the independent sector has done so well for so long, but it is not a universal panacea. What state schools really need is not independent school ‘DNA’, but levels of independent school funding. The fees independent schools charge mean that per pupil funding is typically double or more that of the state sector. With twice as much money to spend it is no wonder that independent schools have lower teacher pupil ratios, more pastoral support and extra curricular activities, and better educational facilities all of which contribute to higher levels of pupil attainment. The state school Heads I work with are uniformly excellent. They manage financially challenging situations and have to extract maximum value from the resources they have; this has honed their leadership and management skills. Their ‘DNA’ is no better or worse than mine, what is different is the level of funding and unfortunately in cash strapped Britain that is unlikely to improve soon. We need to get more resources into state schools, and here it is reasonable that independent schools play an appropriate part by delivering reasonable public benefit.

Public benefit is much discussed but poorly defined. It involves independent schools providing a financial benefit to variously the poor / the state / state schools / local and international communities at least equivalent to the value of the tax reliefs that independent schools receive. How much public benefit is enough is a contentious question. A few wealthy independent schools have endowments that can fund public benefit programmes many times the size of their charitable tax relief without having to charge parents more in higher fees. Many more independent schools have limited fee resources, such that some of the costs of additional public benefit work get transferred to parents in the form of higher fees. If fees rise to pay for more public benefit some parents get priced out of independent education and transfer back to the state. This represents a net transfer of costs back from the private sector to the state, and means that the already squeezed state education budget has to be shared between even more children.

There are thus practical financial limits on the extent of public benefit that independent schools can deliver. There is also a parent fairness dimension. Independent school parents already pay in their taxes for a state education they do not use, so to pay again in higher independent school fees to subsidise state schools through public benefit activities could be seen as unfair. It is all a question of extent, but there will be a fairness cap on public benefit.

The form that public benefit takes is also contentious. In 2011 a judicial review concluded that it should be down to the trustees of each and every charitable independent school to decide what forms of public benefit would do most good in the context of their schools and their communities. This devolved responsibility creates a flexible public benefit system that can adapt to the strengths of independent schools and the needs of the local state sector both of which change through time. Since 2011 there has been a blossoming of a diverse range of public benefit activities. At The Perse these include partnerships with 17 different primary schools to provide educational resources and opportunities including modern foreign language teaching, maths support, science workshops, outdoor pursuits training, computer programming and pupil mentoring. These are all voluntary partnerships which deliver real needs and significant ‘chalk face’ benefits to state school pupils. Perse staff and students also gain from them as teachers have new professional development opportunities and our students acting as classroom assistants and mentors develop their communication, patience, and emotional intelligence skills.

In a Green Paper published in autumn 2016 the government signalled its intention to push for a more prescriptive form of public benefit. Instead of independent school trustees deciding on the form of public benefit, the government would tell the sector what to do. More precisely the public benefit would align with government education policy such that independent schools would be required to sponsor free schools and academies. Understandably independent schools who take no direct money from the government do not like being told what to do by it. They are not keen to be agents of government policy, especially when many have doubts about the wisdom of that policy.

So where does this leave us? In my view it boils down to the following. The quality of state education is compromised by limited resources. Independent schools can and should help state schools address educational shortfalls. Public benefit should not be politicised and used to promote a particular government’s pet educational project. Instead the exact form that public benefit takes should be a matter for the schools involved to decide based on local needs and expertise.

And finally there needs to be a cap and collar on public benefit. We need to agree acceptable maximum and minimum levels of provision. Charitable independent schools must do enough public benefit to justify their charitable status, but not so much that the consequent increase in fees price children out of independent schools and the sector out of existence.

Categories

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Google+
  • Email

Latest Posts

18 Nov 2020

A Personal Perspective on Public Exams in a Pandemic

5 Sep 2020

Learning Covid Lessons

18 Nov 2019

The do’s and don’ts of university interviews

Read moreSee more

Blog Archive

2020

November
1
September
1

2019

November
1
September
2
March
2
February
1
January
1

2018

October
1
July
1
April
1
February
1
January
1

2017

November
1
September
1
March
4
January
1

2016

November
1
October
1
September
1
June
1
January
1

2015

October
1
May
2
February
2
January
2

2014

December
4
November
3
October
1
September
3
August
1
June
1
May
1
April
1
March
3
February
1
January
3

2013

December
2
November
3
October
2
September
4
August
3
July
1
June
3
May
4
April
2
March
3
February
3
January
5

2012

December
2
November
4
October
6
September
7
August
4
July
3
June
3
May
5
April
3
March
4
February
4
January
5

2011

December
3
November
2
Return to startReturn to start

The Perse Pelican
Head: Francesca Heftman
92 Glebe Road
Cambridge
CB1 7TD

T +44 (0) 1223 403940

The Perse Prep
Head: James Piper
Trumpington Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EX

T +44 (0) 1223 403920

The Perse Upper
Head: Ed Elliott
Hills Road
Cambridge
CB2 8QF

T +44 (0) 1223 403800

  • Contact
  • Job Vacancies
  • Our Vision, Values and Aims
  • Term Dates
  • Inspection Report
  • Governors
  • Perse Studio
  • Policies
  • Safeguarding and Child Protection Policy
  • Privacy Notices
  • Disclaimer
  • Website Terms of Use
pelican@perse.co.uk
prep@perse.co.uk
schooloffice@perse.co.uk
Twitter Facebook YouTube Instagram

© The Perse School 2021. All Rights reserved.
Crafted by The District and Chameleon Studios

 
Toggle the navigation
 
The Perse School
Parent Login Calendar Site Search
  • Homepage
  • About us 
    • The Perse Today 
      • Our vision, values and aims 
        • Sustainability 
      • Philosophy 
      • Outreach and Community Partnerships 
      • Governors 
      • Perse in Cambridge 
      • Rooted in History 
        • Timeline 
      • Expanding our Facilities 
    • Summer School 
    • Contact 
      • Open Events 
      • Request Prospectus 
      • Book a Tour 
    • Job Vacancies 
  • Pelican 
    • Admissions 
      • Request Prospectus 
      • Open Morning 
      • Book a Tour 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
        • Nursery and Reception 
        • Years 1 and 2 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Club Pelican 
    • School Life 
      • Home from Home 
      • The School Day 
      • Pelican Behaviour 
      • Newsletter 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet a few of our Pelican staff 
      • Parents’ Association 
  • Prep 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Visiting the Prep 
        • Open Morning 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Taster Morning 
        • Activity Morning 
        • Pre-Test Service 
      • Prep 360 Virtual Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
      • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Assessment 
      • Learning Support 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs 
      • Drama + Music 
      • Sport 
    • School Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The School Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • The House System 
      • School Council 
      • Newsletter 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet a few of our Prep Staff 
      • Parents’ Association 
  • Upper 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Open Days 
      • Visiting the Upper 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Taster Morning 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
      • Fees 
        • Help with Fees 
      • Scholarships 
      • Joining Us 
        • Linking Project 
        • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Independent Research 
      • Enrichment 
      • Exam Results 
      • Learning Support 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs + Societies 
        • The 42 Society 
      • Drama + Dance 
      • Music 
      • Outdoor Pursuits 
      • Sport 
      • Peter Hall Performing Arts Centre 
    • School Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The School Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • The House System 
      • Student Council 
    • People 
      • Staff List 
      • Meet the Staff 
  • 6th Form 
    • Admissions 
      • View Prospectus 
      • Visiting the Sixth Form 
        • Book a Tour 
        • Open Evening 
      • 360 Tour 
      • How to Register 
        • International Students 
      • Fees 
        • Help with Fees 
      • Scholarships 
      • Joining Us 
        • Bus Services 
    • Academic 
      • Curriculum 
      • Subjects 
      • Independent Research 
      • Enrichment 
      • Learning Support 
      • Exam Results 
      • University 
        • University destinations 
    • Beyond Classroom 
      • Clubs + Societies 
        • The 42 
      • Drama + dance 
      • Music 
      • Outdoor Pursuits 
      • Sport 
    • Sixth Form Life 
      • Well-being 
      • The Sixth Form Day 
        • Timetable 
        • Bus Services 
      • Student Council 
    • People 
      • Staff list 
      • Meet the Staff 
  • Alumni 
    • Events 
    • Keep in Touch 
      • OP News 
      • E-Newsletter 
        • Perse Profiles 
        • Into The Archive 
        • Recent Events 
      • Find a Friend 
      • Update Form 
      • Contact Us 
      • Memorabilia 
      • E-Communications 
    • Support Us 
      • Make a Gift 
      • Bursaries 
      • 2021 Leavers’ Gift 
      • Outreach 
      • Legacies 
      • Donor Recognition 
    • Get Involved 
      • Year Group Reps 
      • Networking & Careers 
      • 42 Society Lectures 
    • Notable Alumni 
  • News 
  • Head's Blog
  • Contact
  • Calendar
  • Sport Fixtures
  • Term Dates
  • Close Menu  Close Menu
  • Parent Login
  • Pupil + Staff Login
  • Close Menu  Close Menu
  • Twitter
  • Facebook